Smart Home HQ

    Comparing Medical Alert Systems: Features & Costs

    Comparing medical alert systems: in‑home base, GPS pendant, smartwatch, and caregiver app with local lockbox.

    Introduction

    Medical alert systems connect people to trained agents who can quickly dispatch help during falls, health events, or other emergencies, often with a single button press. When comparing medical alert systems, it is important to look at how they improve on smartphones with one‑press access, better wearability, and 24/7 professional monitoring. Ultimately, the best choice balances day‑to‑day comfort with system reliability and the total cost of ownership.

    Disclosure: This page may contain affiliate links. If you buy through our links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

    Quick summary

    • Core options: in‑home (landline/cellular), on‑the‑go GPS pendants, and smartwatch‑style alerts ✅
    • Key features: 24/7 monitoring, optional fall detection, GPS, caregiver apps, IP67 water resistance, and reliable battery life 🔋
    • Cost ranges: in‑home from $19–$30/mo; mobile GPS from $30–$45/mo; add‑ons (fall detection, spouse coverage) +$5–$15 each; watch models $35–$50/mo. Additionally, activation/device fees may apply 💵

    Note: This guide is informational and not medical advice. If this is an emergency, call your local emergency number immediately.

    Table of contents

    What Medical Alert Systems Are

    • They are:
      • 24/7 monitored devices with a help button and two‑way audio
      • Often wearable or wall‑mounted; sometimes GPS‑enabled for use away from home
      • Systems that can notify family, neighbors, or emergency services
    • They aren’t:
      • A substitute for professional medical care or advice
      • Guaranteed fall‑detection devices (algorithms reduce—but don’t eliminate—missed/false events)
      • Always covered by Medicare. Original Medicare typically doesn’t cover. However, some Medicare Advantage plans may

    Now that you know what medical alert systems are, it helps to compare the main types side by side.

    Comparing Medical Alert Systems

    1. In‑Home Landline Base + Pendant/Bracelet ☎️
    • How it works: base station connects to your phone line; wearable talks to base.
    • Pros:
      • Lowest monthly cost
      • Simple tech for homes with reliable landline
    • Cons:
      • Requires landline; limited range from base (often 400–1,300 ft)
      • No GPS away from home
    • Typical cost: $19–$28/mo (+$5–$10 fall detection)
    1. In‑Home Cellular Base + Pendant/Bracelet 📡
    • How it works: base uses cellular network; no landline required.
    • Pros:
      • Easy install; works during landline outages
      • Battery backup on base (often 24–32 hours)
    • Cons:
      • Range limited to in‑home radius
      • Ongoing cellular fees baked into monthly price
    • Typical cost: $25–$35/mo (+$5–$10 fall detection)
    1. On‑the‑Go GPS Pendant (Cellular) 🏃‍♀️🗺️
    • How it works: single wearable unit with speaker, mic, GPS, and cellular radio.
    • Pros:
      • Works at home and away. Overall, great for active users
      • Caregiver app with live location and geofences
    • Cons:
      • Must be charged every 1–5 days (model‑dependent)
      • Heavier than a simple pendant
    • Typical cost: $30–$45/mo (+$5–$10 fall detection)
    1. Smartwatch‑Style Medical Alert ⌚️
    • How it works: a watch with help button. Also integrates cellular/GPS, step counts; sometimes heart rate.
    • Pros:
      • Discreet and familiar form factor
      • Easy two‑way talk on wrist
    • Cons:
      • Daily/near‑daily charging
      • Smaller speaker/mic than pendants
    • Typical cost: $35–$50/mo (fall detection varies by model)
    1. Hybrid Bundles (Home + Mobile) 🧩
    • How it works: an in‑home base plus a mobile unit for out‑of‑home use.
    • Pros:
      • Best coverage; one plan for both needs
    • Cons:
      • Higher monthly cost; more gear to manage
    • Typical cost: $40–$60/mo (+ add‑ons)

    Beyond device type, specific features can make one system a better fit than another.

    Feature Comparison – Comparing Medical Alert Systems

    • Monitoring center quality 🛎️
      • Look for UL‑Listed/TMA Five Diamond centers. Likewise, bilingual support, and redundant locations.
      • Ask about average response time (often 15–45 seconds).
    • Fall detection (optional) 🧍‍♀️➡️🪑
      • Uses accelerometers/algorithms to auto‑call after a hard fall.
      • Pros: helpful if user won’t/can’t press button; Cons: false alarms. In addition, misses can occur.
      • Cost: +$5–$15/mo.
    • GPS + caregiver app 📍
      • On‑the‑go devices usually include GPS; apps show live/last known location, battery, and alerts.
      • Geofencing can notify caregivers if someone wanders beyond a safe zone.
    • Battery life 🔋
      • In‑home base backup: 24–32 hours typical.
      • Mobile pendants: 1–5 days (usage and signal impact).
      • Watches: often 1–2 days.
    • Waterproof rating 🚿
      • Prefer IP67 (shower‑safe) for wearables; slips often happen in bathrooms.
    • Audio and mic clarity 🎙️
      • Larger pendants/base units usually have louder speakers than watches.
    • Indoor range (in‑home systems) 📶
      • Check pendant‑to‑base range. Also, test from the shower and yard.
    • Connectivity options 🌐
      • Landline vs cellular (AT&T/Verizon networks), and sometimes Wi‑Fi assist.
      • Verify carrier coverage in your area before buying.
    • Accessories 🔐
      • Lockbox (for EMS entry), wall buttons at bed/bath, belt clips, lanyards, and fall‑only buttons.
    • Contracts and policies 📝
      • Month‑to‑month options are common; avoid steep restocking/activation fees.
      • Ask about price‑lock guarantees and prorated refunds.

    Once you understand the features, the next step is to look closely at pricing and hidden fees.

    Cost Breakdown: Monthly, Add‑Ons, and Hidden Fees

    • Baseline monthly
      • In‑home landline: $19–$28
      • In‑home cellular: $25–$35
      • Mobile GPS pendant: $30–$45
      • Smartwatch: $35–$50
    • Common add‑ons
      • Automatic fall detection: +$5–$15
      • Spouse coverage (extra button): +$5–$10
      • Lockbox: one‑time $25–$50
      • Caregiver app (premium features): +$0–$10
    • One‑time fees (ask up‑front)
      • Device/activation: $0–$99 (some promos waive)
      • Shipping: $0–$20
      • Restocking/replacement: varies widely
    • Example scenarios (est.)
      • Budget in‑home (cellular) + fall detection: ≈ $30 + $10 = $40/mo
      • Active user mobile GPS + fall detection: ≈ $35 + $10 = $45/mo
      • Watch bundle (no fall detection): ≈ $40/mo, add fall detection if available

    At this point, you can match the options to your daily routine and risk level.

    Tip: Original Medicare generally doesn’t cover these. However, some Medicare Advantage, Medicaid waivers, or VA programs may. Therefore, check your plan benefits.

    Which Should You Choose?

    • Mostly at home, wants simplicity 🏡
      • Pick: in‑home cellular base + pendant
      • Add: fall detection + bathroom wall button
    • Active lifestyle, walks/drives alone 🚶‍♂️🚗
      • Pick: mobile GPS pendant
      • Add: caregiver app + geofence alerts
    • Prefers a discreet look and watch format ⌚
      • Pick: medical alert smartwatch
      • Add: reminders to charge nightly
    • Couple at home 👵👴
      • Pick: in‑home cellular with spouse pendant add‑on
      • Add: lockbox for EMS access
    • Memory concerns or wandering risk 🧭
      • Pick: GPS pendant with strong caregiver app
      • Add: geofencing and frequent‑check notifications

    Smart Home Tie‑Ins

    • Voice assistants (Alexa/Google) 🗣️
      • Some brands offer skills for status checks or to contact support; however, emergency call flows must follow provider rules.
    • Smart locks + lockbox integration 🔐
      • Share a temporary smart‑lock code with responders or keep a lockbox code on file with the monitoring center.
    • Presence and lighting 🚨
      • Automations can turn on hallway lights if a fall alert is triggered (via hub/integrations where supported).
    • Wi‑Fi planning 📶
      • If your system uses Wi‑Fi (rare; many are cellular), ensure −65 dBm or better near the bedroom/bath.

    Privacy, Security, and Compliance – Comparing Medical Alert Systems

    • Data use and consent 🔒
      • Review privacy policy and app permissions. Also, ensure data sharing is minimal and transparent.
    • Monitoring certifications 🏛️
      • Look for UL‑Listed facilities and TMA Five Diamond. Specifically ask about bilingual agents and disability accommodations (TTY/TDD).
    • Emergency info on file 📄
      • Keep medications, allergies, conditions, and emergency contacts updated with the provider.
    • Not a replacement for 911 🚑
      • For life‑threatening emergencies, call your local emergency number immediately.

    Setup Checklist – Comparing Medical Alert Systems

    • Verify carrier coverage for cellular‑based systems (AT&T/Verizon maps).
    • Place in‑home base centrally. Similarly, test pendant range from the shower, yard, and bedroom.
    • Enable fall detection (if purchased) and perform test drops per instructions.
    • Add caregiver contacts; confirm who gets called first (family vs EMS).
    • Install a lockbox or set up a smart‑lock code for responders.
    • Label chargers and set charging routines (calendar/voice reminders).
    • Document policy terms (trial window, returns, warranty, price‑lock).

    SmarthomeHQ Picks – Comparing Medical Alert Systems

    Frequently Asked Questions – Comparing Medical Alert Systems

    Do I need fall detection?

    It’s optional. However, it helps if the user might not press a button after a fall. Expect occasional false alerts; still, many families find the trade‑off worthwhile.

    Will Medicare cover a medical alert system?

    Original Medicare typically does not. Nevertheless, some Medicare Advantage, Medicaid waivers, or VA programs may include benefits. Therefore, check with your plan.

    Landline or cellular—what’s better?

    Cellular in‑home systems are simpler for most households today. Conversely, choose landline only if your copper phone line is very reliable and you prefer the lowest monthly cost.

    How long do wearable batteries last?

    Mobile pendants often last 1–5 days; watches usually need daily or near‑daily charging; in‑home bases include 24–32 hours of backup.

    Can I use a smartphone instead?

    Yes, but phones can be left behind or locked. Specifically dedicated devices provide one‑press access, water resistance, and professional monitoring.

    Are these waterproof?

    Many wearables are IP67 (shower‑safe). Always verify the rating. Importantly, test audio from the bathroom.

    Join the Conversation!